The Beating Heart Of Internet Politics Conspiratorial populism gets the most engagement online Scott Greer Feb 03, 2026 Jeffrey Epstein is back in the news after the Justice Department released the final cache of files dealing with the deceased sex pest. It displaced all other news on social media. Iran, ICE raids, the economy–all suddenly gone from the internet’s horizon in favor of Epstein. Once again, this Epstein news cycle has prompted confident predictions that Donald Trump is finished and politics will never be the same. If the past news cycles are any indication, none of that will occur. There is news value in the recent Epstein dump, with previously undisclosed connections to the shady financier being exposed. But it’s not the most important thing in the world right now. It is, however, to the internet. The intense interest in the Epstein case demonstrates that conspiratorial populism is the beating heart of internet politics. You can be a communist, a fascist, a resistance li...
Professor Kwasniewski, AI Detective And then we arrive at the Catholic Identity Conference, Michael Matt’s annual Pittsburgh project devoted to “uniting the clans.” This year Peter Kwasniewski is scheduled to speak Friday, October 2, on “The Traditional Latin Mass—What Truly Unites All the Clans.” Bishop Robert Mutsaerts of the Netherlands speaks the next afternoon on “The Catholic Response to a (Synodal) Church in Crisis.” The clans are already uniting beautifully. On September 19, Kwasniewski posted a lengthy complaint about articles he believes are produced by artificial intelligence. Then came his exhibit. Kwasniewski posted a GPTZero scan assigning “100% AI probability” to Bishop Mutsaerts’ recent essay, “The Church in Crisis — and How We Must Not Save Her.” He lamented that such articles “WOULD HAVE BEEN GREAT if they had been written by people” and questioned the ethics of sharing an article “if it’s not written by a person.” There is one small problem. A GPTZero score does not establish authorship. Even GPTZero says so. The company explicitly acknowledges that human writing can be classified as AI and tells educators confronted with a positive result to seek writing history and other evidence. Its own published guidance states that a detector score “should not be treated as proof on its own.” Independent 2026 research makes the point more forcefully. Studies of AI detectors have found contradictory classifications, false positives and significant weaknesses depending upon the kind of writing being tested. One recent study found GPTZero generated false positives on genuinely human texts; another warned that detector results should not be standalone evidence of authorship. Perhaps Mutsaerts used AI. Perhaps he used it for editing. Perhaps a translator or aide did. Perhaps he wrote every syllable himself. Kwasniewski’s screenshot proves none of those possibilities. But why bother asking? Upload. Scan. Anathematize. And then everyone meets in Pittsburgh the following week for the Unite the Clans Mixer. You cannot make this stuff up. Although Professor Kwasniewski may want to run that sentence through GPTZero before believing me.
Michael Matt Calls Our Lady “The Ultimate Feminist” While Dr. Kwasniewski Accuses Fellow Catholic Identity Conference Speaker, Bishop Robert Mutsaerts, of Using AI At a conference devoted to authentic Catholic femininity, Matt recast Our Lady in the language of feminist power. The surrounding Trad Inc. circus makes the problem even clearer. Chris Jackson Sep 29, 2026 Michael Matt went to Littleton, Colorado, last weekend to address a Catholic women’s conference whose stated purpose could hardly have been clearer. Restore Tradition says its mission is to cut through the “delusions of the modern world” and teach “God’s design for men and women.” The conference promised women a rediscovery of “authentic femininity.” On Friday morning, Father Chad Ripperger delivered a talk titled “The Sins of Eve, Feminism and Our Lady.” Abby Johnson followed later that day with “A Personal Journey from Feminism to Authentic Femininity.” So naturally, on Saturday afternoon, keynote speaker Michael Matt ca...