https://theweltgeist.substack.com/p/demographics-is-destiny-no-more-republican-f68?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=5537894&post_id=225711405&utm_campaign=email-post-title&isFreemail=true&r=b9i7w&triedRedirect=true&utm_medium=email Demographics Is Destiny, No More Republican Party: Part 4 Originally posted on The Forge and Anvil on November 23, 2018 Laramie Hirsch Nov 19 READ IN APP Heritage citizens being displaced by the shock troops of the new Economic Zone Imperium* THIS ARTICLE WILL BE ACCESSIBLE ONLY TO BACKERS OF THE WELTGEIST IN 24 HOURS. FREE TO THE PUBLIC UNTIL FRIDAY EVENING. ( UPDATE: 11/19/2026 ) As I prepare this next installment from my 2018 predictions about Republicanism, I cannot help but call to mind the recent NXR convention that took place down in Texas last week. For those that don’t know, “NXR” stands for New Christian Right, and the convention was titled “Christ Is King: America After Trump.” Nick Fuentes was a ...
My central concern with Amoris Laetitia would therefore not be that Francis is a Hegelian. It would be that his pastoral method risks allowing historical circumstances and subjective discernment to acquire an authority over the practical application of universal moral principles that they cannot legitimately possess. That is a much more precise philosophical criticism. And it leads to the question I think is most important for your larger investigation: Is Francis using Thomistic prudence to apply an unchanging moral law to complicated circumstances, or is he introducing a modern theory of discernment in which the concrete situation effectively qualifies the authority of the universal moral law?
would characterize Amoris Laetitia as closer to modern theories of historical consciousness, contextual moral reasoning, and practical discernment than to Hegelianism proper. However, there is a meaningful Hegelian comparison, particularly concerning the relationship between universal principles and concrete historical circumstances. The distinction matters. We should not call Francis a Hegelian simply because he emphasizes development, process, or discernment. Let me distinguish the philosophical currents. I. Hegel: The universal becomes concrete through history File:Jakob Schlesinger - Hegel 1831.jpg - Wikimedia Commons Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770–1831) Hegel understands reality through historical development, contradiction, and mediation. Truth is not adequately understood by isolating an abstract proposition from the concrete process in which it becomes intelligible. Hegel's philosophy emphasizes Becoming . In simplified terms: Reality is not adequately understood as...