Skip to main content

Posts

Google AI Overview Historian Juan Miguel Zunzunegui characterizes friar Bartolomé de las Casas as a "narcissistic liar" whose writings exaggerated the realities of the Spanish conquest. He views Las Casas's legacy as the primary origin of the "Black Legend," which unfairly demonized the Spanish.Zunzunegui's Perspective on Las Casas and the Black LegendExaggeration and the Black Legend: Zunzunegui argues that Las Casas's Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias contained wildly exaggerated figures and distorted realities, claiming absurdly high death tolls where population figures didn't even support such numbers. He contends that this work served as the foundation of the anti-Spanish propaganda known as the Black Legend.Weaponization by European Rivals: According to Zunzunegui, leaders like William of Orange used, altered, and circulated Las Casas's texts during the Eighty Years' War to depict Spain as an uniquely cruel and barbaric empire.The Hispanic Roots of Mexico: Zunzunegui, who is known for his revisionist, hispanist approach to Mexican history, emphasizes that the narrative of a violent, invasive Spanish conquest overlooks the reality of extensive indigenous alliances, the vast cultural and structural foundations laid in the Americas, and the historical reality that modern Mexico is deeply rooted in its Hispanic heritage.For a deeper look into his critique of traditional history and his defense of the Hispanic legacy, you can explore Zunzunegui's discussions on the El Mundo Article on Zunzunegui or read his book Hernán Cortés: Encuentro y Conquista.

AI Overview +6 Mexican writer and historian Juan Miguel Zunzunegui characterizes friar Bartolomé de las Casas as a "narcissistic liar" whose writings exaggerated the realities of the Spanish conquest. He views Las Casas's legacy as the primary origin of the "Black Legend," which unfairly demonized the Spanish. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] Zunzunegui's Perspective on Las Casas and the Black Legend Exaggeration and the Black Legend: Zunzunegui argues that Las Casas's Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias contained wildly exaggerated figures and distorted realities, claiming absurdly high death tolls where population figures didn't even support such numbers. He contends that this work served as the foundation of the anti-Spanish propaganda known as the Black Legend. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] Weaponization by European Rivals: According to Zunzunegui, leaders like William of Orange used, altered, and circulated Las Casas's texts d...
Post a Comment
Read more
Recent posts

Zunzunegui, the Mexican historian against the Black Legend: Mexican historian...is highly critical, even of Bartolomé de las Casas, the Dominican friar who denounced the excesses committed by the nation at the beginning of the American epic, whom he calls a "narcissistic liar."

https://www.elmundo.es/papel/historias/2024/11/12/673249c2fc6c830e508b459e.html Zunzunegui, the Mexican historian against the Black Legend: "Spain was not an unfortunate country that had enslaved colonies: we were an empire" The academic defends the legacy of the Spanish empire on both sides of the Atlantic and is highly critical of the false myths that still persist: "Spain is our father country and America, our mother country," he says. 81 comments Jorge Benítez (Text) Bernardo Díaz (Photography) Updated Tuesday, November 12, 2024 -  00:38 If Philip II had hired Juan Miguel Zunzunegui as press secretary, the Black Legend spread by England and the Netherlands against the Spanish Monarchy would have been quickly dispelled, and Spain would be more associated with a Christmas advertisement for El Almendro than with the Inquisition, the rape of Indigenous women, or the terror the Duke of Alba inspired in Flanders. This 49-year-old Mexican historian, who has thousands o...
Post a Comment
Read more

Zunzunegui: Is this negative image due, in part, to the Black Legend—and does it still persist? — It is very important not to overuse the term "Black Legend." There is a Black Legend, of course. Bartolomé de las Casas lies from start to finish; he speaks of 24 million deaths in a region where there weren't even 24 million inhabitants to begin with. It is absurd. I do not know why Bartolomé de las Casas would have done such a thing; what is abundantly clear, however, is that right in the midst of the Dutch War of Independence against Spain—the Eighty Years' War—William of Orange, the leader of the Dutch, took Bartolomé de las Casas’s *A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies*, distorted it, exaggerated it, and embellished it with horrific details. Furthermore, he commissioned lithographs depicting two Spaniards sawing an indigenous person in half, or twenty indigenous people hanging as if they were hams. And, of course, one must understand that engravings in the 17th and 18th centuries were the photographs—or the artificial intelligence—of their time. A mind from that era would look at such an engraving, exclaim "How horrible!" and swear that they were witnessing reality. No—you were looking at a drawing created specifically to make you think exactly that. What we must not do today is dismiss every negative comment made about us as merely part of the Black Legend; to overuse that claim would strip us of all credibility.

https://www.eldebate.com/historia/20241203/zunzunegui-no-hay-ninguna-conquista-espanoles-fueron-recibidos_243227.html Juan Miguel Zunzunegui, académico, historiador y escritor mexicano Zunzunegui: «No hay ninguna conquista, los españoles fueron recibidos» «Cuando tú construyes una catedral que te lleva 200 años construirla, eso no es una colonia, te estás quedando a vivir ahí», explica Zunzunegui Gonzalo Jiménez Tapia 03 dic. 2024 - 04:30 10 Compartir Save La llegada de los españoles a lo que después llamarían América ha sido cuestión de debate y malas interpretaciones gracias en parte a la leyenda negra y el desconocimiento de la propia historia. Conversamos con  Juan Miguel Zunzunegui , historiador, académico y divulgador mexicano que ha dedicado parte de su estudio y difusión a revisar de forma crítica esa historia de América y México que nos han contado en escuelas y universidades. Añádenos como favoritos en Google — ¿Qué se enseña sobre la Hispanidad en México y otros países d...
Post a Comment
Read more