Skip to main content

If Francis is a Heretic, What should Canonically happen to him?


If Francis is a Heretic, What should Canonically happen to him?

Unknown said…
In regard to this quote from St. Francis de Sales:

“[T]he Pope… WHEN he is EXPLICITLY a heretic, he falls ipso facto from his dignity and out of the Church, and the Church MUST either deprive him, or, as some say, declare him deprived, of his Apostolic See.”
(The Catholic Controversy, by St. Francis de Sales, Pages 305-306)

The translation of this passage is incorrect. The same edition (Tan) from which this is excerpted gives in an appendix the original French. The correct translation would be (omitting the first few words): "... he falls ipso facto from his dignity out of the Church, and the Church must either DEPRIVE HIM, AS SOME SAY, OR DECLARE him deprived, of his Apostolic See." (words capitalized to show the change)

The words "as some say" belong with the former possibility (he must be deprived), not the latter (declare him deprived). This may seem to be a minor difference (though it does not excuse the error of the translator). However, the clear implication appears to be that St. Francis considers the latter opinion, which is that of St. Robert Bellarmine and the more or less unanimous opinion since, to be the definitive one, and is only mentioning the first because it was held by some authors. Thus, the correct position of the qualifying phrase is important, though for the author's polemical purpose in this pamphlet, it was not necessary for him to go into this particular aspect of the question. The semi-Conciliarist idea that a pope can be deposed, in the literal sense, has no support at all (even implicit) from the three Doctors of the Church since the Council of Trent (St. Robert Bellarmine, St. Francis de Sales, and St. Alphonsus de Liguori).

A point of less importance, which might be considered just a stylistic flourish on the translator's part. The word "and" following "he falls ipso facto from his dignity" does not occur in the French. So the exact translation is "he falls ipso facto from his dignity out of the Church." I think this expresses more vividly that falling from his dignity and falling out of the Church are one and the same action. The manifest heretic falls out of the Church by his own act; his dignity is attached to the Church, not to himself; he cannot take it with him when he departs from the Church, any more than when he dies.

At any rate, if St. Francis de Sales had wished to write "and," he could have done so.

The French text runs as follows: "Or quand il est hérétique exprès ipso facto il tombe de son grade hors de l'Eglise et l'Eglise le doit ou priver comme disent quelques uns, ou le declarer privé de son siège apostolique ..." (p. 388 of Tan Books edition, 1989; photostatic reprint of the original: London: Burns and Oates, and New York: Catholic Publication Society, 1886, as v. III of the series "Library of St. Francis de Sales.")

One can only wish that every Catholic would study this truly golden book, and then consider by what possible stretch of the mind Vatican II and all its fruits can be considered Catholic.


Popular posts from this blog

"The West Does Not Understand the Extreme Danger from Its Arming of Ukraine The Idiot Biden Regime and Insane Neoconservatives Have the World on the Path to Armegeddon"

Paul Craig Roberts wrote: How Many More Red Lines Can Be Crossed Before Armageddon Arrives? Paul Craig Roberts The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe published on April 15, 2016, more than six years ago, a report on the torture of Donbass Russians by the Ukrainian military and police forces.   The report documents horrendous torture and it was done out of racial hatred of Russians. You can read the report here:     Few Westerners, being so poorly educated, are aware that Western Ukraine fought for Nazi Germany during World War II.   When Washington overthrew the Ukrainian government in 2014, Washington installed a Nazi government. The Nazi government in Ukraine shelled the Russian residents of the two break-away Donbass republics for 8 years while Washington and NATO trained and equipped a Ukrainian army to retake the breakaway republics. .. ... These statements from Russian leaders indicate that the I

Vox Cantoris vs. Aqua

The Catholic Monitor commenter Aqua had this to say to the Vox Cantoris website: Aqua said… Fred, your topic here reminds me of a dust-up, a few days ago, on Vox Cantoris. He asserted that it is our duty as Christians to wear masks to the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass if the government tells us we must, or they will close our Churches. My response to him was that I find it inconceivable that an orthodox Catholic, such as himself, would ever submit to unjust dictates from secular government over how we approach Our Lord in Holy Mass. My response to him was that the Mass belongs to Catholics and we decide, within the bounds of Tradition, and in accord with the Word of Jesus, how we conduct ourselves in Holy Mass. Only one authority prevails over Mass and that is our God and the Sacred Tradition given by Him to guide us in all times and places. Understand, there is nothing inherently wrong with wearing a mask to Mass. But there is EVERYTHING wrong with wearing a symbol

Mainstream Media: "Is America the Real Victim of Anti-Russia Sanctions?" & "Biden's arrogant anti-Russian sanctions have amounted to a price hike on working class Americans that have so far failed to weaken the Russian economy"

  Mainstream Media Acknowledges Biden’s “Arrogant” Sanctions On Russia Are Damning Americans:     @MaxBlumenthal Biden's arrogant anti-Russian sanctions have amounted to a price hike on working class Americans that have so far failed to weaken the Russian economy. His neocon policy accelerates the process of de-dollarization, diplomatic isolation & imperial decline. The mainstream new outlet asked "Is America the Real Victim of Anti-Russia Sanctions?": Remember the claims that Russia’s economy was more or less irrelevant, merely the equivalent of a small, not very impressive European country? “Putin, who has an economy the size of Italy,” Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., said in 2014 after the invasion of Crimea, “[is] playing a poker game with a pair of twos and winning.” Of increasing Russian diplomatic and geopolitical influence in Europe, the Middle East, and East Asia, The Economist asked in 2019, “How did a country with an economy the size of Spain … ach