The great significance of Ockham is that his Atomism was united to his Nominalism, and thus constituted a specific attack upon the metaphysics of St. Thomas. From that point we can gaze upon an ever-increasing tide of Atomism engulfing the West – people like Bruno, Bacon, Galileo, Gassendi, Descartes, and onward through all the empiricists, phenomenologists, etc. We must also include Luther among the Nominalists
https://www.thecatholicmonitor.com/2019/09/thomism-is-remedy-for-mad.html
By James Larson
Such “science” makes accidents into substance, and makes substance into
an accidental appearance for which we have no explanation except the
subjectivity of our own minds. Thus we end up in that philosophical
idealism which will plague Western man from Plato through all the
nightmare of relatively modern Western Philosophy – from the Nominalism
of Ockham to contemporary Phenomenalism.
This whole tradition of reductive analytical science can be viewed as
sort of a “diabolical transubstantiation.” After engaging in such
analysis, accidents remain as the real substance, and our normal
perception of substantial reality is reduced to “appearances.”
Analytical science then becomes the perfect anagram of reality,
in which the “word” or “logos” of God’s creation is perfectly inverted,
turned upside down, and read backward. I fully believe that the same
force which draws a Man to say the Mass backward or invert a Crucifix is
the same as that which was at the source of the “Greek Miracle.”
In other words, what is effected by the Greek Perversion is not, as
postulated by Daniel-Rops, merely a substitution of rational knowledge
for faith. Rather, what occurs is the most profound perversion of the
inner consciousness and intellect [and thus “rationality” itself) of man
at a level which is bound eventually to destroy any possibility of
faith in God. This, of course, is Satan’s Master Plan. He desires not
only the destruction of myriads of individual souls, but also that final
alteration of human consciousness which makes it impossible not only to
believe in God, but even to desire Him.
In the ancient Greek world, this reductionism reached its pinnacle in
the Atomism of Leucippus, Democritus and, most of all, Epicurus, who
formulated a logical structure to the theory of Atomism which would
remain practically unchanged for the next 2,000 years. With Atomism,
philosophical Idealism is in a very real sense completed. Substance
becomes totally invisible and unrelated to normal human perception,
objective reality ceases to exist as something graspable by the human
intellect, subjectivity and idealism triumph, and, matter replaces God
as being eternal and infinite.
With some notable exceptions, Atomism was suppressed in the West by
Christian realism and the power of the Church from the 1st century AD
until the time of the Renaissance. Since the Renaissance consisted
largely of the “reawakening” of Greek and Roman culture and thought, the
reemergence of Atomism was bound to happen. It exploded upon the scene
at the very beginning of the Renaissance in the person of William of
Ockham. The great significance of Ockham is that his Atomism was united
to his Nominalism, and thus constituted a specific attack upon the
metaphysics of St. Thomas. From that point we can gaze upon an
ever-increasing tide of Atomism engulfing the West – people like Bruno,
Bacon, Galileo, Gassendi, Descartes, and onward through all the
empiricists, phenomenologists, etc. We must also include Luther among
the Nominalists – he was educated at the University of Erfurt, which was
under the control of professors who were Nominalists. Luther himself
detested Thomism and opted for the Nominalism of Ockham, which denied
the minds ability to grasp universals and the substantial forms of real
things.
Comments