Skip to main content

Key passages in Amoris Laetitia recycle article by Argentine ‘ghostwriter’, claims blogger

https://catholicherald.co.uk/key-passages-in-amoris-laetitia-recycle-article-by-argentine-ghostwriter-claims-blogger/

Key passages in Amoris Laetitia recycle article by Argentine ‘ghostwriter’, claims blogger

New questions have been raised about Pope Francis’s apostolic exhortation, as it emerged that controversial passages closely resemble those in two articles written by one of the Pope’s Argentine advisers.

The blogger Sandro Magister has pointed to resemblances between Chapter 8 of Amoris Laetitia and writings by Archbishop Victor Manuel Fernández, a theology professor at the Universidad Católica Argentina in Buenos Aires.

Archbishop Fernández is known to be a close associate of Francis, and to have helped draft the exhortation. Magister describes him as the exhortation’s “ghostwriter”.

However, the revelations suggest that some of Amoris’s most contentious paragraphs – relating to “situations of sin” and “mitigating factors” – had their origin in Archbishop Fernández’s articles, which gave a critique of John Paul II’s encyclical Veritatis Splendor.

In the two articles, written in 2005 and 2006, Archbishop Fernández reflected on the Catechism’s teaching that those who commit grave sins are not necessarily in a state of mortal sin.

The Catechism states that mortal sin “results in the loss of charity and the privation of sanctifying grace, that is, of the state of grace”, and that if it is not repented of, it leads to “the eternal death of hell”.

But the Catechism adds: “Although we can judge for ourselves that an act is in itself a grave offence, we must entrust judgment of persons to the justice and mercy of God.”

In the 2006 article, Archbishop Fernández argues that this could apply to Catholics who have difficulty understanding or obeying Church teaching, and are unable to follow it. Quoting another writer, he discusses situations where someone “does not find himself in subjective conditions to act differently or to understand ‘the values inherent in the norm’, or when ‘a sincere commitment to a certain norm may not lead immediately to verify the observance of said norm’.”

This passage seems to be consciously echoed in Amoris Laetitia’s paragraph 301: “A subject may know full well the rule, yet have great difficulty in understanding ‘its inherent values’, or be in a concrete situation which does not allow him or her to act differently and decide otherwise without further sin.”

This paragraph of the exhortation has been criticised by theologians including E Christian Brugger, who argued that it apparently goes against Church teaching: “This seems to contradict the defined doctrine in Trent on Justification, canon 18: ‘If any one says the commandments of God are impossible to keep, even by a person who is justified and constituted in grace: let him be anathema.'”

The suggestion that this and other passages – including paragraphs 300, 302 and 305 – are chiefly the work of Archbishop Fernández will add to the controversy over Chapter 8 of the exhortation.

When asked about footnote 351 of the article – which made an ambiguous reference to access to the sacraments for the divorced and remarried – Pope Francis said he could not remember it.

Earlier this month Robert Spaemann, one of the most highly-regarded Catholic philosophers in Europe, told an interviewer that he thought the document contradicted Church teaching.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

My good friend ( now deceased ), Mother Teresa of the Still River Mass convent , called me years before the McLucas story broke.

https://akacatholic.com/cmtv-vs-sspx/ Latest Comments 2Vermont JULY 30, 2019 I think the only thing I would add here is what seems like MV’S obsession with things of a sexual nature. Tom A JULY 30, 2019 He, like many, defend the institution with the zeal that should be used to defend the Faith. Sad. What Mr. Voris fails to admit is that it is the institution of the conciliar fake church that is the biggest enemy of the Faith. Lynda JULY 30, 2019 Blinded by secular values and prestige of man. coastalfarm JULY 30, 2019 Please see the article “Unmarked building, quiet legal help for accused priests” Dryden, Mich. (AP) for the priest Mr. Voris defends, Rev.Eduard Perrone of Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary Church also known as Assumption Grotto, is co-founder of Opus Bono Sacerdotii. This non-profit organization takes in accused priests and gives them shelter, legal defense, transportation, etc. Opus Bono claims to have helped over 8,000 priests and has raised over $8 million 2002-201

Might Biden be a Liar & Predator like McCarrick?

September 15, 2020   Everyone knows that sexual predator ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick is a liar. His whole life was a lie of betrayal of the most sacred vows he took and the violation of the moral tenets of the Catholic faith which he desecrated. Most people don't realize that part of this desecration of lies included lying for "gravely sinful" Democrats like Joe Biden. McCarrick protected Biden when then head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later to be Pope Benedict XVI) wrote that bishops were not to admit to Communion politicians like "gravely sinful" Biden who supports the killing of unborn babies. McCarrick lied for politicians like Biden by ignoring the important parts of the Ratzinger letter and told bishops not to ignore the Catholic Church law.  Last year, Fr. Robert Morey denied Holy Communion to the “gravely sinful” Biden following a "2004 decree signed jointly by the bishops of