Skip to main content
Fr. Gruner: "this person said oh well five years doesn't work I'm not I'm going to I'm going to get a divorce well then is is clear they never" terms for am marriage 5:00 and therefore what is null it never took 5:03 place and what the annulment is is to 5:06 declare upon examining the issues and 5:09 questions coming up it comes out that 5:11 this person said oh well five years 5:12 doesn't work I'm not I'm going to I'm 5:14 going to get a divorce well then is is 5:16 clear they never wasn't and the 5:18 difference is is why you have priests on 5:20 these Marriage is to say to ask the right 5:22 questions did you really have this 5:24 intention or did he have some other
hello and welcome to your questions answered with father gruner I'm John vaner in this program we take your questions father gruner answers them we talk about them have discussions uh please continue to send us these questions at questionsthe fatmac center.com we have a question today about uh what's called annulments I'll just read what it says is is a person who has received an analment from a diois tribunal free to marry again is there any doubt about the validity of a subsequent marriage I have always believed that one could only enter into a second marriage if the first partner was deceased so I think it comes down to an understanding of what the word analment means well I think that so so an analment is not a divorce okay so and and so the what is it what is but before we even talk what analment is we have to talk about what marriage is okay so a marriage sacramentally speaking John I know you know this and you can perhaps feel in things I might leave out but the idea is that the sa marriage is actually takes place it's the priest is not the minister of the sacrament the priest is the official witness now the priest for saying mass or absolving from sins or baptizing he is the minister but in the case of of marriage it's not the priest who's the minister of the sacrament it's the each person administering to the the couple so the whole idea is that marriage is quite un unique is that it's a contract what I mean by a contract I mean you have to I don't want to sound either cold or commercial but a contract even for for for let's say no money at all is John I agree to give you this in return for I want you to come to my house tomorrow and bring over a cup of tea for me okay so I have to sign a contract for that I the idea but the idea is it's it's an agreement a contract is agreement but a contract is a more formal agreement so I mean and but you sign a contract with someone who's going to put a new roof on your house yeah and that's a commercial want leave contract out of being commercial the idea is it's not what it's certainly an example of a contract if you know you put a new roof on your house and the supplier says I'll do this and you give me this much money and and you know give me access to the house and this and that and I'll do this for such and such that's but the whole idea is that you're agreeing to something I'm agreeing to something and we're making exchange and we're fulfilling our end of the contract by by doing what we said we're going to do but in the case of marriage it's is also a contract it's not a commercial contract it is an agreement between a man and a woman it has to be a man and a woman but so this the man and the woman who are not married already so that's the first thing and that they are capable of marriage so a child for example 10 years old or 5 years old cannot marry not because they're they're humans but they're not they are not capable of marriage yet so they can't get married yet because they need to be adult humans I might say first of all so the whole point I'm getting at is that the sa of marriage is the contract between the man and the woman to to accept the woman accepts the man as her husband the man accepts the woman as his wife and that is there's two people in the contract there's a third person in the contract the third person is God and God says you can't get married to each other unless you agree to my fundamental terms of this contract which is that your your Every Act of procreation is open to children now whether God wants to send you children or doesn't send you children that's God's choice but the act of procreation has to be open to that so if a person gets married for example goes through more exactly goes through a ceremony if a man and a woman goes through a ceremony saying I'm going to marry x and x is going to marry y but X is saying to himself all along but I'm not going to have any children I'm going to do whatever it takes for me not to have any children while enjoying the benefits of the act of procreation well that is not a marriage because God says I will not bless that it's not according to my terms if a man if x gets married to Y in another case and says I'll marry Y and I'll marry X but if it doesn't work out in 5 years I'm going to get a divorce well God also hasn't blessed that marriage because that's not the marriage is forever so if in their hearts and their consent they've already said I'm not going to have respect accept any children although I'll use The Marriage Act or I'm not going to marry for for life even though okay I made a bad choice X wasn't what I thought it was or wasn't what she I thought she was he was the point is if we have made that contract already with those terms in our own we have not been married in the first place and why am I bringing this up is because in those cases there was never a marriage even though they went through a ceremony even though they said I do they didn't really mean I do and therefore there never was a contract and a Meeting of Minds and hearts to agree to something that that was also in Conformity with with God's uh conditions and terms for am marriage and therefore what is null it never took place and what the analment is is to declare upon examining the issues and questions coming up it comes out that this person said oh well five years doesn't work I'm not I'm going to I'm going to get a divorce well then is is clear they never wasn't and the difference is is why you have priests on these Mar is to say to ask the right questions did you really have this intention or did he have some other intention because after a while we need the marriage is a difficult it's a blessing but it also has its crosses and so you need The Graces for the marriage so if a marriage Falls breaks apart it could be because they're not being faithful to Grace but also could be because they haven't had the grace in the first place because there never was a marriage because God didn't give them the blessing and therefore they don't have this because they broke one of the fundamental rules in the very Act of getting married so all an analment is is declaring that that marriage never took place in the first place yes they went through a ceremony yes they said I do yes they you know they lived this man and wife for how many years but no there was not an actual contract and agreement of a fundamental point on these fundamental points I'm not going through the whole thing but I'm just trying to get the point is that if a tribunal does its job properly properly and it discovers that there are grounds such as not accepting children you know just we're going to use the Marriage Act but we're not going to accept children and that was their intention from day one from the time they they they aged then and I I mean they think I'm making this up they can look up Cy kobbi that's by pi the pi 11th in 1930 is encyclical he makes it very clear there's never not that he's the only it's been taught by that to the church all the time he was pronouncing what the teacher is and the same thing he says the same thing about for if a person say going to get married and for it's also in Cy kobbi so those are not the only cases but those are two cases which are classic for which they ad do and tribal could say if they have the authority say after examining the witnesses under oath and everything else and we've discovered there's no marriage and it certainly can be you can be as certain as as anything on if those are the two cases you know but I mean and there's other grounds for enement besides but the point I'm trying to get at here is the person says I always believe a person only second marriage to the first partner died if you were married to the first partner you're absolutely correct that is if you truly had a marriage with that your husband your wife then you can't get married to anybody else you can't have a you can't have a divorce you're you're you're I mean For Better or Worse you're you for better great or For Worse you're stuck but anyway that's what it is but in the case of uh if they never had a marriage in the first place then there's grounds for enement now I can't say well you know since I had this I self administer to myself okay why declare I'm anel no we we have to go through while God is joined together nobody can put us under including the partners themselves yes so I don't know if that's answer question well I think to the question comes up because right now uh we're going through a period in church history where there was a tremendous amount of abuse regarding an nments yes where they're just um they're coming up with fanciful reasons and and um they it's really just a Catholic divorce yeah and so uh that's why um I mean of course it's not Catholic but it's it's yeah yeah it's a it's a figure of speech I know of of a woman uh who went to I won't even say what dicese it is but she went to see the the vicer general of the dasis who no who's ever the head of the tribunal sure and of course there's you know there's a number of reasons why um that make one eligible to for an moment and she sat down and the mon sior sat down he threw the paper at her and said pick reason in other words just you know you want to make this happen we'll make it happen yeah and um so and my senor Smith I love this story my senior Smith who was a moral Theologian at at Dunwoody Seminary he said he was talking to another Theologian who was much more Progressive and they were at a restaurant so-called Progressive but anyway yeah was he was he was a modernist and uh and uh this man this uh to uh my senior Smith I I've never seen a marriage that couldn't be an old right and my senior Smith said don't say that in public yeah that's stupid shall we start with your parents you know you so um so there's been a lot of abuse in in anman so even dealing with the dases on these points uh one has to be very careful that they're following the the rules the real whole thing is this that obviously if they're giving an analment on the basis of solid grounds I've given two I'm not given all of them then the nment would be valid if the analment if it's done for some specious reason or done in this place that says oh give you take a reason I'll fill it out and get you the that's obious they haven't got the right attitude they it's it's a it's a very serious job I mean it's it's enough work you know I mean it's it's it's a it's a it's a sacrifice it's a cross-like marriage also why priest put a soul in hell because he makes two people who are not happy with their marriage with each other and I'm just going to give you a divorce I'll fill the proper forms all the rest of it I mean it's a serious business why am I going to put myself in hell because of their mistakes I mean you know I I'm not refusing to do the the DU diligence and you feel you you feel sympathy for for people but I mean these people are these priests and taking attitude I I mean I'm sorry but uh if I were their Confessor and you're not going to repent I certain not going to bet on your chances of heaven so uh so anyway get but getting back to the uh the whole business of the analment that if the the the church has established that these the um I I don't know the exact term for granting an anol is not quite well the grounds for an grounds for analment that the grounds for anman exist and so and that's what the word means that the marriage was null to begin with so there was no marriage declaration that the marriage never took place right I mean I know of a case and and I presume all of them are dead today I know certainly one partner is dead but the the the the woman in in this case and I I don't know her name and I've never met her but I know this the details of the well I'm trying to get it as thought she did not understand what marriage was in the first place I mean you know it's I mean I'm sure there's men who can be as ignorant like that but in this case it was a woman and so when she said I do she didn't even know what she was agreeing to I mean subsequent events brought that out and her marriage was ened at the highest level of the church about 10 years later my point only being that there are every case can be different but there's no way that everybody doesn't understand but there can be some unusual cases and and but there are very for example one of the things is a cont make it very simple if you're going to give me this paper John and you're saying I'm giving it to you I have to the assumption is that this paper belongs to you and you can give it to me okay but if you are in fact married to somebody else you cannot say I do I can marry you because I'm already married to someone else so if a person and there are cases you know in certainly upheavals war time what not people the person's missing an action for five years they married to somebody else because everyone believed he was dead and he shows up one day well all was done in good faith but the fact is still married to the original and that's those are the kind of things that can't happen there I mean history of course we got 7 billion people well everyone has their own life story so you know some things go wrong sometimes so that's why we have marriage tribunals but it's not every marriage just can't be no no so anyway um there's a lot to talk about regarding marriage and annulments especially marriage hopefully we'll deal with this topic uh uh even more now than this so this sinot is coming up in 2015 and uh we'll uh close this program and we will pick it up next time thank you
Comments